Poverty & Safety Net
Article

Where is the justice? Addressing racial disparities in the juvenile justice system

Community Solutions Team
Transforming data into progress
Additional Contributors
No items found.
April 8, 2019
Read time:
Download Fact Sheets
Register now
Share this resource
Subscribe to our Newsletter
By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download this as a PDF

 

This is the third blog in a series responding to the infographic report on racial disparities in Cleveland that I authored in December. You can go back and read the first blog on infant mortality and the second blog on racial disparities in childhood.  

It would be impossible (and irresponsible) to write anything about the criminal justice system without also writing about race. The racial disparities in the system are astounding and unjust. This blog will focus on youth, among whom racial disparities in commitment rates are actually widening, not narrowing.[1] This is because while many states, including Ohio, have made efforts to decrease juvenile imprisonment on the whole, diversion programs and interventions have disproportionately benefited white youth. As the infographic above points out, this problem begins long before young people become involved with the juvenile justice system. Black children are more likely than white children to be disciplined in school, beginning as early as pre-school. As they grow into adolescence, they are more likely to be criminalized for common youthful indiscretions, while white youth are given second and third chances. And when it comes to serious crimes, which can land young people in one of the state’s three juvenile correctional facilities, it is important to consider the root causes of those violent crimes. Young people who commit violent crimes are often from impoverished communities where gang violence and drug activity are widespread, and access to guns and other weapons is common. It is equally important to address these root issues, as it is to make reforms within the criminal justice system itself.

 So, what is happening in Ohio, and Cuyahoga County specifically, to reduce racial disparities and protect black youth from harmful interactions with the criminal justice system? What more should we be doing?

Prevent Justice Involvement Early: Keep Kids in Classrooms

As of November 2, 2018, House Bill 318, which is designed to improve school safety and keep young students in classrooms by limiting suspensions, went into effect in Ohio. The bill provides additional funding to schools for school safety, and also eliminates out-of-school suspensions and expulsions (except in the case of serious violent offenses) for students in pre-K through third grade. Since research shows that early school discipline is a predictor for future justice involvement, this bill has the potential to be a helpful improvement in coming years as it is phased in, especially for young children of color who are more likely to be disciplined at a young age. The school safety funding can be used in a number of ways, including training for school resources officers, active shooter training and training to “identify and assist students with mental health issues.” [2] Many advocates recommend that schools focus less on spending funds on school resource officers, and instead focus on improving access to mental health services in schools as an evidence-based practice to improve school safety. This approach could also serve to prevent justice involvement among students.

 Many advocates recommend that schools focus less on spending funds on school resource officers, and instead focus on improving access to mental health services in schools as an evidence-based practice to improve school safety.

Focus Juvenile Justice Reform on Disparity Reduction

Late last year, Congress passed the Juvenile Justice Reform Act of 2018. Title II of the bill “gives clear direction to states and localities to plan and implement data-driven approaches to ensure fairness and reduce racial and ethnic disparities, to set measurable objectives for disparity reduction, and to publicly report such efforts.” [[3]](http://www.njjn.org/uploads/digital-library/JJDPA Reauthorization Summary December 2018.pdf) How Ohio will implement these reforms and report progress is yet to be seen, but this is an opportunity for the state to move toward real change in the system that could benefit youth of color, who are frequently not given the benefit of the doubt. The bill also implements numerous system improvements which will have a positive impact on all youth in the juvenile justice system.

 The bill gives clear direction to states and localities to plan and implement data-driven approaches to ensure fairness and reduce racial and ethnic disparities, to set measurable objectives for disparity reduction, and to publicly report such efforts.

Support Equitable Diversion Programs

In Ohio, it costs the state $202,502 annually to imprison one youth. [4] But youth incarceration isn’t just expensive—it is harmful to young people in countless ways.[5] Enter: diversion programs. Diversion programs are funded in a variety of ways and can take many forms, but broadly, they are community-based alternatives to juvenile detention. Read more about youth deincarceration in this report. The goal is to spend less, keep young people in their communities, and focus on reform, rather than detain them in state facilities. As I mentioned earlier, one challenge with diversion programs is that they frequently disproportionately benefit white youth. As a result, it is important that juvenile courts, police departments, schools and community-based service providers to work together to proactively consider how the system can equitably serve young people, bearing in mind that underlying issues, such as over-policing of poor minority neighborhoods and gang violence in the urban core, are contributors to the overrepresentation of black youth in the system. The Cuyahoga County Juvenile Court is actively taking on the issue of addressing racial and ethnic disparities in its system—the Juvenile Detention Alternatives Initiative (JDAI) has formed a racial and ethnic disparity subcommittee that is actively working to reduce disparities.[6]

 Youth incarceration isn’t just expensive—it is harmful to young people in countless ways.

Improve Data Collection and Reporting Capacity

One issue that came up repeatedly as I researched this system is the glaring lack of available data from both the juvenile and adult criminal justice systems. Only a tiny minority, less than 5 percent, of cases in Ohio’s Juvenile Justice Courts have comprehensive data.[7] The lack of data makes it challenging to fully understand the issues in the system in order to address them (check out this infographic for more info about this data gap). Having access to robust, disaggregated data is vital in order to continue to examine racial disparities within the system and create reform.

 Having access to robust, disaggregated data is vital in order to continue to examine racial disparities within the system and create reform.

In an upcoming post, I will address how Cuyahoga County and Ohio are addressing racial disparities in the adult criminal justice system. Stay tuned.  

I would like to thank the following people who shared their knowledge and perspectives with me as I researched this piece: Erin Davies, Juvenile Justice Coalition; Bridget Gibbons, Cuyahoga County Juvenile Court; Judy Wright, Ohio Transformation Fund  

[1] https://www.sentencingproject.org/publications/racial-disparities-in-youth-commitments-and-arrests/  

[2] http://jjohio.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/HB-318-Summary-as-signed-into-law-8.28.18.docx.pdf  

[3] http://www.njjn.org/uploads/digital-library/JJDPA%20Reauthorization%20Summary%20December%202018.pdf  

[4] http://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/factsheet%5Fcosts%5Fof%5Fconfinement.pdf  

[5] http://www.justicepolicy.org/images/upload/06-11%5Frep%5Fdangersofdetention%5Fjj.pdf  

[6] http://juvenile.cuyahogacounty.us/pdf%5Fjuvenile/en-US/AnnualReports/2016AnnualReport.pdf  

[7] http://jjohio.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Infographic-Denied-Existence-6.23.16.pdf

Download Fact Sheets

District 10

Download

All Council Districts 2024

Download

District 4

Download

District 2

Download

District 11

Download

District 9

Download

District 8

Download

District 5

Download

District 7

Download

District 1

Download

District 3

Download

District 6

Download

West Boulevard

Download

University

Download

Union-Miles

Download

Tremont

Download

Stockyards

Download

St.Clair-Superior

Download

Old Brooklyn

Download

Ohio City

Download

North Shore Collinwood

Download

Mount Pleasant

Download

Lee-Seville

Download

Lee-Harvard

Download

Kinsman

Download

Kamm's Corners

Download

Jefferson

Download

Goodrich-Kirtland Park

Download

Glenville

Download

Fairfax

Download

Euclid-Green

Download

Edgewater

Download

Downtown

Download

Detroit Shoreway

Download

Cudell

Download

Collinwood-Nottingham

Download

Clark-Fulton

Download

Central

Download

Buckeye-Woodhill

Download

Buckeye-Shaker Square

Download

Brooklyn Centre

Download

Broadway-Slavic Village

Download

Bellaire-Puritas

Download

All Neighborhoods 2024

Download

West Boulevard Factsheet

Download

University Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Union-Miles Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Tremont Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Stockyards Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

St. Clair-Superior Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Old Brooklyn Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Ohio City Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

North Shore Collinwood Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Mount Pleasant Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Lee-Seville Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Lee-Harvard Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Kinsman Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Kamm's Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Jefferson Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Hough Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Hopkins Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Goodrich-Kirtland Park Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Glenville Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Fairfax Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Euclid-Green Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Edgewater Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Downtown Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Detroit Shoreway Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Cuyahoga Valley Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Cudell Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Collinwood-Nottingham Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Clark-Fulton Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Central Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Buckeye-Shaker Square Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Brooklyn Centre Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Broadway-Slavic Village Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Bellaire-Puritas Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

All Neighborhoods 2016

Download

District 2

Download

District 1

Download

Ohio Women Statewide

Download

All Women Fact Sheets

Download

Wyandot Women

Download

Wood Women

Download

Williams Women

Download

Wayne Women

Download

Washington Women

Download

Warren Women

Download

Vinton Women

Download

Van Wert Women

Download

Union Women

Download

Tuscarawas Women

Download

Trumbell Women

Download

Summit Women

Download

Stark Women

Download

Shelby Women

Download

Seneca Women

Download

Scioto Women

Download

Sandusky Women

Download
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download report

Subscribe to our newsletter

5 Things you need to know arrives on Mondays with the latest articles, events, and advocacy developments in Ohio

Explore the fact sheets

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique.

No Related Fact Sheets

Explore Topics

Browse articles, research, and testimony.

Poverty & Safety Net
Article

Sixty-one health and human service levies appear on ballots across Ohio

Kyle Thompson
October 21, 2024
Medicaid
Article

Setting the Medicaid Growth Rate

Brandy Davis
October 21, 2024
Poverty & Safety Net
Article

Staying nonpartisan when everyone is talking about the upcoming election

Emily Campbell
October 21, 2024
Older Adults
Article

Council on Older Persons (COOP): Older adults ensure strong neighborhoods

Community Solutions Team
October 17, 2024