Maternal & Infant Health
Public testimony

May 19, 2022: House Bill 496, Families, Aging & Human Services Committee on Midwives and Maternal Health

May 19, 2022
Read time:
Download Fact Sheets
Register now
Share this resource
Subscribe to our Newsletter
By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download this as a PDF

 Hope A. Lane-Gavin, Health Equity Fellow Loren C. Anthes, MBA, Treuhaft Chair, Sr. Fellow  

House Families, Aging & Human Services Committee Chairwoman Manchester May 19, 2022  

Chairwoman Manchester, Vice Chairman Cutrona, Ranking Member Denson and members of the House Families, Aging, and Human Services Committee, thank you for the opportunity to provide proponent testimony today on House Bill 496. My name is Hope Lane and I’m a Fellow for Health Equity with The Center for Community Solutions, a nonprofit, nonpartisan think tank that aims to improve health, social and economic conditions through research, policy analysis and communication. I am joined today by my colleague Loren Anthes. Before we begin, please note we have provided copies of our research in addition to this testimony that can provide further details and analysis you may find useful.  

We have had the opportunity to come before this body on numerous occasions this General Assembly to speak about our work in the maternal and infant health space and we are eternally grateful that this legislature recognizes how crucial this work is for our state and thus continues to prioritize public policy to make significant improvements.

Historical Birthing Practices

For most of Colonial America and well into the 19th century, all births occurred in the home, an overwhelming majority of which were attended by lay midwives who also provided most of all medical care to the entire family with little to no formal training. ​Medical practice was not professionalized​ and most “doctors” were men and men did not attend births. Starting in the 20th century, the combination of medicine becoming professionalized in the United States and the rise in medical advances led to births becoming more institutionalized. This is why, in 1900, less than 5 percent of women gave birth in hospitals, but by the early 1920’s up to 50 percent of women gave birth in hospitals. ​  

While innovations in medicine meant there were many improvements in outcomes for complex deliveries, many Black and poor families did not have access to safe, well-funded and well-equipped hospitals nor health insurance and thus continued to use midwives for family planning and basic primary care. However, as institutional settings became more prominent in delivery, and as the medical industry became advanced, midwifery became more regulated, functionally prohibiting the practice as a readily available service to manage low-risk pregnancies. At the same time, there was a significant increase in the number of surgically-enabled deliveries, with cesarean section rates going from less than 2.5 percent in the 50s to over 30 percent by 2004. With this increased rate of c-sections, which is a major intrusive and invasive surgery, maternal mortality and morbidity also increased, with the risk of maternal death 3.6 times higher and risk of postpartum infection 5 times higher after a cesarean is performed.

14 counties in Ohio have no hospital offering obstetric care, no birth center, and no obstetric provider

This issue of access is still a problem, mind you, where in 2020, 1,095 counties in the United States lacked maternity care (no hospital offering obstetric care, no birth center and no obstetric provider), including 14 counties in Ohio. House Bill 496 is also an attempt to address the realities of health care provider shortages and maternity deserts by expanding and diversifying the perinatal workforce and broadening what it means to have maternity care. House Bill 496 forces us to look at the midwives in our state, many of which are in this room, who have largely been accredited and recognized by a national board that are prepared, trained and able to care for those expecting and ask why we aren’t utilizing their expertise to its full capacity to help address maternal and infant health outcomes in our state.  

Studies have shown that those who received midwifery services experienced a lower chance of epidural usage, labor induction, labor augmentation, use of intravenous fluids, instrumental vaginal birth (forceps/vacuum), amniotomy (breaking of water) and episiotomy. Additionally, mothers who have access to midwifery services have a lower chance of preterm birth, are less likely to lose their babies under 24 weeks of gestation and the odds of severe maternal morbidity do not increase. So where are we in Ohio and how does HB 496 address these issues? I will ask my colleague Loren Anthes to finish our testimony by reviewing Ohio’s current regulatory landscape and discuss the implications HB 496 has on cost containment and competition.  

Chairwoman Manchester, Vice Chairman Cutrona, Ranking Member Denson and members of the House Families, Aging, and Human Services Committee, thank you for the opportunity to provide proponent testimony today on House Bill 496. My name is Loren Anthes, and I’m a Sr. Fellow with The Center for Community Solutions. I will provide you with a brief overview of Ohio’s regulatory landscape when it comes to midwifery and the benefits of the legislation in regards to cost efficiency and access.

Midwife licensure in Ohio

Currently, Certified Nurse Midwives (CNM) are the only legally-enabled professional midwife type to practice in Ohio. As established in Ohio Revised Code (ORC) Section 4723.41, there are several requirements for CNMs, including licensure as an advanced practice nurse with an application for practice in the specialty concurrent with a license fee. Also, as a provider designated in Ohio’s State Plan in Medicaid, CNMs are eligible for Medicaid reimbursement, which pays for half of all childbirths in our state. Beyond CNMs, then, the de jure professionalization of Certified Midwives (CMs) and Certified Professional Midwives (CPMs) does not exist in Ohio, significantly limiting the freedom of Ohioans to select their delivery setting and birthing options. As such, midwifery is under the functional authority of hospitals, meaning deliveries are concentrated in institutional settings versus community-based or home-based settings. Under this system, we have created a regulatory environment defined by significant barriers to entry for these trained clinicians to offer their services in our state, reducing access and options for families.

Ohio ranks 46th in infant deaths and 39th in infant mortality rate

In 2018, a multidisciplinary team of maternal and infant clinical experts produced a study called the Access and Integration Maternity Care Mapping (AIMM) Study. The point of AIMM was to evaluate the statistical relationship between the integration of midwives into delivery processes and assess the impact in terms of outcomes. Through this work, the group developed the Midwifery Integration Scoring System (MISS), where higher scores indicate greater integration of midwives across all settings. Using reliable indicators in the Centers for Disease Control-Vital Statistics Database, the MISS identifies the correlation coefficients between integration scores and maternal-newborn outcomes by state. When looking at Ohio, we rank 46 out of 50 states in regards to midwifery integration. States that ranked highly, including Alaska, Arizona, Montana, New Mexico and Washington state have successfully integrated midwifery into the normal course of care and reimbursements for a generation and their outcomes prove such. I should also note Ohio ranks 46 in the number of infant deaths it has ranks 39 in infant mortality rate. And despite our best efforts to protect infants and mothers through policy, we continue to see high rates of infant and maternal deaths in Ohio. A major reason for this challenge is because Ohio does not have a pathway to clinical integration for Certified Professional Midwives or Certified Midwives.  

Beyond the benefit in outcomes that Hope noted, cost savings are apparent when midwife legalization is made possible in community-based settings. Currently, there is a wide variance in expense associated with normal delivery and cesarean sections in Ohio and across the United States, especially when compared to other industrialized nations. This variance is difficult to explain in concrete terms, but the expense generally is driven by an institutional approach to delivery. To explain the scale of this problem, realize that the cost of hospitalizing moms and babies for birth in the United States is .6 percent of our GDP, which is the entire GDP of Hungary, or nearly $130 billion annually. The reason being, as complex medical facilities, tertiary medical centers like hospitals have high fixed costs with high salaried practitioners, complex equipment and large campuses with significant infrastructure. And, while there is certainly an advantage to have these resources for high-risk medical interventions, it’s important to appreciate the level of need for the entirety of a hospital’s resources is not always necessary for effective, efficient delivery.

Low-risk births are significantly less expensive when performed by a midwife

This is borne out in the data as well, which suggests services for low-risk births are significantly less expensive when performed by a midwife. For example, in a 2019 University of Massachusetts study, researchers found that childbirth costs for low‐risk women with midwife‐led care were, on average, $2,262 less than births to low‐risk women cared for by obstetricians. Similarly, in a 2019 study from the American Journal of Managed Care, data from 2010 indicated average facility charges for freestanding birth centers were $2,277, while hospitals charged an average facility fee of $10,166 for an uncomplicated vaginal birth – an 87.7 percent difference. In Ohio, the average price for normal delivery, one of the most common services performed in a hospital, is $16,106. For a c-section, it’s $21,431. For some hospitals, the rates of c-sections are as high as 70 percent, with the average around 32 percent, nationally, and most industrialize nations at 28.1 percent.  

We believe the bill’s sponsor has done a laudable job accommodating the concerns and feedback of professionals in the field, ensuring safety and autonomy are preserved. As a result, House Bill 496 achieves a number of policy goals to improve the delivery landscape in Ohio by developing policies that will increase access, lower costs and achieve better outcomes. Chairwoman Manchester, Vice Chairman Cutrona, Ranking Member Denson and members of the House Families, Aging, and Human Services Committee, thank you for the opportunity to provide testimony. We’d be happy to answer whatever questions you may have.  

Download Fact Sheets

District 10

Download

All Council Districts 2024

Download

District 4

Download

District 2

Download

District 11

Download

District 9

Download

District 8

Download

District 5

Download

District 7

Download

District 1

Download

District 3

Download

District 6

Download

West Boulevard

Download

University

Download

Union-Miles

Download

Tremont

Download

Stockyards

Download

St.Clair-Superior

Download

Old Brooklyn

Download

Ohio City

Download

North Shore Collinwood

Download

Mount Pleasant

Download

Lee-Seville

Download

Lee-Harvard

Download

Kinsman

Download

Kamm's Corners

Download

Jefferson

Download

Goodrich-Kirtland Park

Download

Glenville

Download

Fairfax

Download

Euclid-Green

Download

Edgewater

Download

Downtown

Download

Detroit Shoreway

Download

Cudell

Download

Collinwood-Nottingham

Download

Clark-Fulton

Download

Central

Download

Buckeye-Woodhill

Download

Buckeye-Shaker Square

Download

Brooklyn Centre

Download

Broadway-Slavic Village

Download

Bellaire-Puritas

Download

All Neighborhoods 2024

Download

West Boulevard Factsheet

Download

University Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Union-Miles Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Tremont Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Stockyards Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

St. Clair-Superior Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Old Brooklyn Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Ohio City Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

North Shore Collinwood Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Mount Pleasant Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Lee-Seville Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Lee-Harvard Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Kinsman Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Kamm's Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Jefferson Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Hough Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Hopkins Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Goodrich-Kirtland Park Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Glenville Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Fairfax Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Euclid-Green Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Edgewater Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Downtown Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Detroit Shoreway Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Cuyahoga Valley Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Cudell Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Collinwood-Nottingham Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Clark-Fulton Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Central Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Buckeye-Shaker Square Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Brooklyn Centre Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Broadway-Slavic Village Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

Bellaire-Puritas Neighborhood Factsheet

Download

All Neighborhoods 2016

Download

District 2

Download

District 1

Download

Ohio Women Statewide

Download

All Women Fact Sheets

Download

Wyandot Women

Download

Wood Women

Download

Williams Women

Download

Wayne Women

Download

Washington Women

Download

Warren Women

Download

Vinton Women

Download

Van Wert Women

Download

Union Women

Download

Tuscarawas Women

Download

Trumbell Women

Download

Summit Women

Download

Stark Women

Download

Shelby Women

Download

Seneca Women

Download

Scioto Women

Download

Sandusky Women

Download
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download report

Subscribe to our newsletter

5 Things you need to know arrives on Mondays with the latest articles, events, and advocacy developments in Ohio

Explore the fact sheets

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique.

No Related Fact Sheets

Explore Topics

Browse articles, research, and testimony.

Maternal & Infant Health
Public testimony

Maternal mental health: HCR 16 Proponent Testimony

Natasha Takyi-Micah
June 5, 2024
Behavioral Health
Public testimony

Proponent Testimony on HB 300: remote treatment of opioid use disorder

Dylan Armstrong
April 29, 2024
Maternal & Infant Health
Public testimony

Hospital licensing, maternal and infant health data in Ohio

Community Solutions Team
March 1, 2024
Poverty & Safety Net
Public testimony

Provisions to Improve the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program’s Quality Control System

Community Solutions Team
November 23, 2023
Maternal & Infant Health
Public testimony

October 11: House Public Health Policy Committee

Community Solutions Team
October 11, 2023