Article

Census data is the gold standard, immigration questions would tarnish it

Emily Campbell
Chief Executive Officer
Additional Contributors
No items found.
March 26, 2018
Read time:
Download Fact Sheets
Register now
Share this resource
Subscribe to our Newsletter
By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download this as a PDF

The research team at The Center for Community Solutions frequently fields questions about community conditions and our go-to source for information is data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau. Census data has all the qualities of a good friend: it is trustworthy, dependable, and interesting.

The biggest threat comes from misguided recommendations to ask questions about legal immigrant status.

Since policymakers, researchers and community leaders rely so heavily on Census data, we need that data to provide as fair and accurate a count as possible. Unfortunately, there are proposals circulating in Washington which would weaken the 2020 Census and the more extensive data the Census Bureau provides annually in its American Community Survey (ACS). The biggest threat comes from misguided recommendations to ask questions about legal immigrant status.

Census data not only determines how we are represented in Washington, it helps determine where more than $400 billion in federal funding goes each year. The Census Bureau, state and local partners work hard to encourage people to respond if they are randomly selected to fill out a survey. The better the response rate, the better the information available. Anything that discourages a household from responding to Census questionnaires makes census data less reliable, and can threaten our ability to compile and analyze information for small geographies at the local level, such as by Cleveland Ward or Ohio legislative district.

Anything that discourages a household from responding to Census questionnaires makes census data less reliable

April 1 is the deadline for the Census Bureau to submit the questions to Congress in preparation for Census 2020. Any recommendations to ask questions about legal immigrant status are misguided. This would undermine data collection efforts, while providing little useful data and could impact information available in every community across the country.

There is a difference between immigration status (whether someone was born in the U.S.) and legal status (how the individual entered the country or what type of visa they hold). The American Community Survey already asks about place of birth, country of origin and when an immigrant came to the U.S. This information is useful to quantify conditions facing individuals who recently arrived in this country, and to understand the composition of communities and their possible needs.

The Census Bureau reported “unprecedented” levels of concern from focus group participants about the confidentiality of data they provide.

Asking about legal status would be overly intrusive, and could lead some households to provide false answers which would jeopardize the quality and usefulness of all of the data. The Census Bureau reported “unprecedented” levels of concern from focus group participants about the confidentiality of data they provide. There is the danger that traditionally marginalized populations will be less likely to participate in the census, causing undercounts of certain racial and ethnic groups, people with lower incomes and those living in unstable housing arrangements. This question could jeopardize the accuracy of the entire Census, leaving policymakers, funders and community organizations with bad information on which to base decisions. We need a fair and accurate Census. Without it, Ohio may not be appropriately represented, federal funding could flow away from communities that truly need it and Community Solutions’ community profiles would be nearly blank.

Download Fact Sheets

Geauga County

Download

Lake County

Download

Cuyahoga County

Download

Thompson

Download

South Russell

Download

Russell

Download

Parkman

Download

Newbury

Download

Munson

Download

Montville

Download

Middlefield Township

Download

Middlefield Village

Download

Huntsburg

Download

Hambden

Download

Claridon

Download

Chester

Download

Chardon Township

Download

Chardon City

Download

Burton

Download

Bainbridge

Download

Auburn

Download

Willowick

Download

Willoughby Hills

Download

Willoughby

Download

Wickliffe

Download

Waite Hill

Download

Timberlake

Download

Painesville City

Download

Mentor-on-the-Lake

Download

Mentor

Download

Madison

Download

Lakeline

Download

Kirtland Hills

Download

Kirtland

Download

Eastlake

Download

Concord

Download

Highland Heights 2018

Download

Garfield Heights 2018

Download

Fairview Park 2018

Download

Euclid 2018

Download

East Cleveland 2018

Download

Cleveland 2018

Download

Cleveland Heights 2018

Download

Cities in Cuyahoga County Combined 2018

Download

Brooklyn 2018

Download

Brook Park 2018

Download

Broadview Heights 2018

Download

Brecksville 2018

Download

Berea 2018

Download

Bedford 2018

Download

Bedford Heights 2018

Download

Beachwood 2018

Download

Bay Village 2018

Download

Westlake 2018

Download

Warrensville Heights 2018

Download

University Heights 2018

Download

Strongsville 2018

Download

South Euclid 2018

Download

Solon 2018

Download

Shaker Heights 2018

Download

Seven Hills 2018

Download

Rocky River 2018

Download

Richmond Heights 2018

Download

Pepper Pike 2018

Download

Parma 2018

Download

Parma Heights 2018

Download

Olmsted Falls 2018

Download

North Royalton 2018

Download

North Olmsted 2018

Download

Middleburg Heights 2018

Download

Mayfield Heights 2018

Download

Maple Heights 2018

Download

Lyndhurst 2018

Download

Lakewood 2018

Download

Independence 2018

Download

Woodmere

Download

Westlake

Download

Warrensville Heights

Download

Walton Hills

Download

Valley View

Download

University Heights

Download

Strongsville

Download

South Euclid

Download

Shaker Heights

Download

Seven Hills

Download

Rocky River

Download

Richmond Heights

Download

Pepper Pike

Download

Parma Heights

Download

Orange

Download

Olmsted Falls

Download

Olmsted

Download

Oakwood

Download

North Royalton

Download

North Randall

Download
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download report

Subscribe to our newsletter

5 Things you need to know arrives on Mondays with the latest articles, events, and advocacy developments in Ohio

Explore the fact sheets

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique.

No Related Fact Sheets

Explore Topics

Browse articles, research, and testimony.

Poverty & Safety Net
Article

ARPA 3 Years later: Lessons learned in Ohio

Dylan Armstrong
November 18, 2024
Poverty & Safety Net
Article

New Human Services Chamber launching in December

Emily Campbell
November 17, 2024
Maternal & Infant Health
Article

Neighborhood Family Practice partners with Birthing Beautiful Communities

Taneisha Fair
November 11, 2024
Poverty & Safety Net
Article

U.S. Census to halt publication of state-level hardship data

John R. Corlett
November 11, 2024