Medicaid
Public testimony

Public Comment to the Ohio Department of Medicaid: Ohio Department of Medicaid Proposal for Substance Use Disorder Treatment

November 21, 2018
Read time:
Download Fact Sheets
Register now
Share this resource
Subscribe to our Newsletter
By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download this as a PDF

The Center for Community Solutions

November 21, 2018

Introduction  

As a nonpartisan think tank actively engaged in the development of sound, cost-effective Medicaid and behavioral health policy, The Center for Community Solutions welcomes the opportunity to provide public comment on the Ohio Department of Medicaid’s (ODM) proposed 1115 demonstration for substance use disorder (SUD) treatment.[1] Community Solutions recognizes the need for the state to seek waiver authority to ensure that Ohio Medicaid’s recently restructured behavioral health benefit remains compliant with federal restrictions that limit Medicaid’s ability to pay for residential treatment. Federal law has long prohibited Medicaid from paying for behavioral health services provided in residential facilities with more than 16 beds, often called “institutions for mental disease” (IMD). In recent years, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) have issued guidance allowing state Medicaid programs to pay for short-term stays in IMDs via managed care contracts,[2] along with additional guidance for states to seek waiver authority to circumvent the IMD exclusion.[3] Ohio now joins 27 other states that have submitted IMD waivers for SUD treatment, including 17 that have already been approved.[4]

 Federal law has long prohibited Medicaid from paying for behavioral health services provided in residential facilities with more than 16 beds, often called “institutions for mental disease”

While Ohio’s demonstration proposal represents a continuation of the policies initiated through the state’s Behavioral Health Redesign, this waiver will serve as a more formal contract between the state and CMS to define Medicaid’s ability to pay for services provided in IMDs. IMDs have long been an area of uncertainty for Ohio Medicaid providers and beneficiaries, even after the implementation of Behavioral Health Redesign. The 1115 proposal provides an opportunity for ODM to establish complete transparency around Ohio’s IMD policy. ODM can do this by releasing a complete implementation plan for this demonstration project, developed with robust stakeholder input. Although an implementation plan is required by CMS prior to approval of all 1115 waivers, the plan is not required to accompany the waiver application at the time of submission. Because ODM has yet to release its implementation plan, there remains a degree of uncertainty around the precise implications of the proposal for the behavioral health system in Ohio. The Center for Community Solutions proposes several recommendations, outlined below, for ODM to consider in its implementation plan to promote performance evaluation, quality, and data transparency in Ohio’s SUD demonstration.  

Recommendation 1: Develop an “IMD HEDIS Score” Tied to Performance

The state has made significant efforts to tie the Healthcare and Effectiveness Data and Information Set (HEDIS) into its quality efforts with its contracted managed care plans. Currently, Ohio’s behavioral health measures are tied mostly to mental illness.[5] These measures, where possible, should be amended to include substance use disorder (SUD). What’s more, there are several other HEDIS measures that should be deployed and tied to Ohio’s Pay for Performance (P4P) program.  

These measures could include, but are not limited to:  

EFFECTIVENESS OF CARE

  • Follow-up after emergency department visit for alcohol and other drug abuse or dependence;
  • Medicaid management and care coordination, including transitions of care.ACCESS/AVAILABILITY OF CARE
  • Initiation and engagement of alcohol and other drug abuse or dependence treatment.UTILIZATION
  • Identifications of alcohol and other drug services;
  • Mental health utilization.MEASURES COLLECTED USING ELECTRONIC CLINICAL DATA SYSTEMS
  • Depression screening and follow-up for adolescents and adults;
  • Utilization of the PHQ-9 to monitor depression symptoms for adolescents and adults;
  • Depression remission or response for adolescents and adults;
  • Unhealthy alcohol use screening and follow-up.

Recommendation 2: Create a Certificate of Need Process for IMD Beds

While Ohio is grappling with the opioid crisis, the current landscape of available providers and utilization patterns is largely unknown. What’s more, the increase of availability of these services could provide a perverse incentive for new market entrants to provide services with no incentive to connect back to community-based services. This may have the effect of significantly increased spending and institutionalization.

 Like the Certificate of Need process[6] associated with nursing facilities, a data-driven process of “bed allocation” should be developed in a transparent and regularly reported manner for IMD providers

Like the Certificate of Need process[6] associated with nursing facilities, a data-driven process of “bed allocation” should be developed in a transparent and regularly reported manner for IMD providers. Additionally, nursing facilities should either be excluded from providing IMD services or at least be required to forego existing beds intended for consumers of other long-term care services. Recent federal guidance (see Recommendation 4) explicitly prohibits nursing facilities from participating as IMDs in 1115 demonstration projects for treatment of severe mental illness.[7] ODM should seek clarity on whether CMS maintains this policy toward nursing facilities for SUD treatment as well.  

Ultimately, individuals with substance use disorders and mental illness should be supported in ways that are oriented toward community-based options and recovery as a matter of civil rights and cost-effective, recovery-oriented care.  

Recommendation 3: Create a Public Resource on Capacity, Spending and Utilization and Develop a Working Group to Address Issues  

It is important that transparency remains a part of this time-limited demonstration effort. Doing so would not only provide CMS the appropriate resources to evaluate the waiver, but it would empower consumers and policymakers with the data needed address the challenges of a fragmented behavioral health delivery system. These resources should include:

  • Number and location of providers, including their service portfolio listened in a manner consistent with the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) criteria; This should be posted online and updated regularly;
  • Spending associated with services provided by general ASAM standard;
  • Information on transitions of care between settings, including the average days between an inpatient level of care and a community-based treatment option;
  • General demographics of the individuals served;
  • Information on health conditions including:  
  • Mental health conditions  
  • SUD  
  • Other chronic diseases  
  • Number that have more than one of the above indicators  
  • Per member per month cost associated with each category
  • Information submitted to CMS as a part of the terms and conditions of the waiverIn addition to the data outlined, the state should form a working group made up of governmental staff on the state and local levels alongside representatives from the industry and managed care. This group should meet quarterly to review the data being developed and determine ways in which the waiver could be improved. In particular, LeanOhio[8] should be engaged to employ process efficiency tactics when needed, including the development of a process map that outlines the continuum of care expected by the state in its proposal.  

Recommendation 4: Provide Clarification on Mental Health Services in IMD Settings by Responding to New Federal Guidance  

The proposed demonstration waives the IMD exclusion only for SUD services, following CMS guidance issued in the November, 2017 State Medicaid Directors Letter (SMD Letter).[9] However, in the November 13, 2018 SMD Letter (issued after ODM published its draft proposal), CMS announced a demonstration opportunity for states to seek 1115 waiver authority to provide mental health treatment for short-term residents of IMD with serious mental illness (SMI).[10] CMS offers technical assistance for states who have already submitted an SUD waiver proposal to operationalize the existing waiver with the SMI waiver. In its implementation plan for Ohio’s SUD proposal, ODM should explain if and how it plans to work with CMS to integrate coverage of SMI in an IMD setting into the demonstration project.  

Conclusion  

Community Solutions recognizes that ODM’s 1115 demonstration proposal for SUD treatment is a necessary and logical next step in Ohio’s modernization and transformation of the Medicaid behavioral health benefit. However, the implementation plan for the demonstration is a complex and important piece of public policy that should establish a comprehensive and transparent framework for the delivery of IMD services in Ohio Medicaid moving forward. This implementation plan should be developed carefully with stakeholder input, and be responsive of recommendations such as those described above.  

[1] https://medicaid.ohio.gov/RESOURCES/Public-Notices/Substance-Use-Disorder-Treatment-Waiver-Proposal  

[2] http://files.kff.org/attachment/CMSs-Final-Rule-on-Medicaid-Managed-Care  

[3] https://www.medicaid.gov/federal-policy-guidance/downloads/smd18011.pdf  

[4] https://www.kff.org/medicaid/issue-brief/medicaid-waiver-tracker-approved-and-pending-section-1115-waivers-by-state/  

[5] https://medicaid.ohio.gov/Portals/0/Medicaid%20101/QualityStrategy/Measures/SFY2017-HEDIS-Aggregate-Report.pdf  

[6] https://www.odh.ohio.gov/odhprograms/dspc/certn/certneed1.aspx  

[7] https://www.medicaid.gov/federal-policy-guidance/downloads/smd18011.pdf  

[8] https://www.lean.ohio.gov/  

[9] https://www.medicaid.gov/federal-policy-guidance/downloads/smd17003.pdf  

[10] https://www.medicaid.gov/federal-policy-guidance/downloads/smd18011.pdf

Download Fact Sheets

Ohio Statewide Data

Download

Wood County

Download

Wyandot County

Download

Williams County

Download

Washington County

Download

Vinton County

Download

Wayne County

Download

Warren County

Download

Van Wert County

Download

Union County

Download

Tuscarawas County

Download

Stark County

Download

Summit County

Download

Trumbull County

Download

Shelby County

Download

Seneca County

Download

Scioto County

Download

Ross County

Download

Sandusky County

Download

Richland County

Download

Putnam County

Download

Huron County

Download

Portage County

Download

Preble County

Download

Pike County

Download

Pickaway County

Download

Perry County

Download

Noble County

Download

Paulding County

Download

Ottawa County

Download

Morrow County

Download

Muskingum County

Download

Morgan County

Download

Montgomery County

Download

Meigs County

Download

Monroe County

Download

Miami County

Download

Mercer County

Download

Marion County

Download

Madison County

Download

Medina County

Download

Mahoning County

Download

Lucas County

Download

Lorain County

Download

Logan County

Download

Licking County

Download

Lawrence County

Download

Lake County

Download

Holmes County

Download

Jackson County

Download

Knox County

Download

Jefferson County

Download

Hocking County

Download

Henry County

Download

Highland County

Download

Harrison County

Download

Hancock County

Download

Hardin County

Download

Greene County

Download

Geauga County

Download

Guernsey County

Download

Hamilton County

Download

Gallia County

Download

Fayette County

Download

Fulton County

Download

Franklin County

Download

Fairfield County

Download

Erie County

Download

Darke County

Download

Defiance County

Download

Coshocton County

Download

Delaware County

Download

Cuyahoga County

Download

Crawford County

Download

Columbiana County

Download

Clinton County

Download

Clermont County

Download

Clark County

Download

Champaign County

Download

Carroll County

Download

Athens County

Download

Ashtabula County

Download

Brown County

Download

Butler County

Download

Belmont County

Download

Auglaize County

Download

Ashland County

Download

Allen County

Download

Adams County

Download

Lake County

Download

Geauga County

Download

Cuyahoga County

Download

All Municipalities Geauga County

Download

All Municipalities Lake County

Download

All Municipalities Cuyahoga County

Download

Thompson

Download

South Russell

Download

Russell

Download

Parkman

Download
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Download report

Subscribe to our newsletter

5 Things you need to know arrives on Mondays with the latest articles, events, and advocacy developments in Ohio

Explore the fact sheets

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique.

No Related Fact Sheets

Explore Topics

Browse articles, research, and testimony.

Medicaid
Public testimony

Federal Public Comment Opposing Medicaid Work Requirements

Brandy Davis
April 14, 2025
Poverty & Safety Net
Public testimony

SB 29 testimony: Restore stolen SNAP EBT benefits and enact anti-fraud measures

Rachel Cahill
April 7, 2025
Behavioral Health
Public testimony

HB 96 testimony: On legalizing life-saving fentanyl testing equipment

Dylan Armstrong
March 10, 2025
Medicaid
Public testimony

HB 96 Public Testimony: Medicaid expansion provision

Tara Britton
February 27, 2025